The new type of Shabbat elevator allowed by some of the Halachic judges, receives a dramatic turn after the letter of the Rabbi Rosenblatt that was revealed in ‘Bahaderi Haredim’. The great Israelis, the Rabbi Edelstein and the Rabbi Lando, ruled in opinions that this is a complex issue and due to the substance of the Sabbath prohibition. Do not use these elevators on Shabbat
The uproar regarding the training of the Shabbat elevators that first arose in ‘Bahaderi Haredim’ following the letter of the rabbi of Bnei Brak, the Gaon Rabbi Shabach Zvi Rosenblatt, who banned the elevators after permits were received from several rabbis and halachic judges who allowed their use in a certain way, takes a turn this morning (Friday) with the publication of a letter named The great men of Israel, Rosh Yeshiva Geriz Edelstein and Geriz Lando, Rosh Yeshiva Selvodka, who prohibit the use of elevators.
After they tried to permit them: the judge forbids the use of Shabbat elevators
In the letter they wrote The Gaon Rabbi Yitzchak Mordechai HaCohen Rubin Mehr Nof and the Gaon Rabbi Shalom Yosef Gelber from the authors of the books ‘Arhot Shabbat’ along with the Rabbi of Bnei Brak the Gaon Rabbi Shari’el Rosenbarrg they return from the permission.
The letter states: “The leadership of the community is entrusted to the great and the elders of the generation, and here is the matter of what we needed to test a new type of Shabbat elevator, which seemed to the NDA to be designed in a way that there is no fear of desecration of the Shabbat 16, when we came to Kamiya from Rabbanan, from the head of the Yeshiva HaGaon Rabbi Gershon Edelshtin Shalita and Maran the Great Gaon Rabbi Dov Lando Shalita we heard their opinions on the whole matter of the use of new renewable electrical devices for mornings, even those that seemed to have no concerns at all, in any case these are complex issues in which new problems are discovered every day. .--
“Also, the very permit for elevators has a lot to discuss, since in the future new problems may arise, including the use of Shabbat elevators of all types, and in their great opinion in all of this, due to the substance of the Shabbat prohibition, these elevators should not be used at all
In the Shin Bet and Yot”.
This is a dramatic letter that closes any possibility of granting kosher to the Shabbat elevators. And we rejected the revolutionary plans according to which the use of Shabbat elevators was increased for the first time in the city of Bnei Brak as part of the evacuation of construction and the construction of high-rise towers with a special permit for contractors.
‘Bahaderi Haredim’ learned that Rabbi Rosenblatt’s letter sparked the matter anew after they had already tried to allow it through an article in Beitad Na’eman, this morning with the dramatic letter